Essay: We Can But Dare We

NR360 We Can But Dare We.docx Revised 5 ‐ 9 ‐ 16 DA/LS/psb 07.14.16 1

NR360 INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN HEALTHCARE

Required Uniform Assignment: We Can, but Dare We?

PURPOSE The purpose of this assignment is to investigate smartphone and social media use in healthcare and to apply professional, ethical, and legal principles to their appropriate use in healthcare technology.

 

Course Outcomes This assignment enables the student to meet the following course outcomes.

• CO #4: Investigate safeguards and decision‐making support tools embedded in patient

care technologies and information systems to support a safe practice environment for

both patients and healthcare workers. (PO 4)

 

• CO #6: Discuss the principles of data integrity, professional ethics, and legal

requirements related to data security, regulatory requirements, confidentiality, and

client’s right to privacy. (PO 6)

• CO #8: Discuss the value of best evidence as a driving force to institute change in the

delivery of nursing care (PO 8)

DUE DATE See Course Schedule in Syllabus. The college’s Late Assignment Policy applies to this activity. Essay: We Can But Dare We

 

TOTAL POINTS POSSIBLE This assignment is worth a total of 240 points.

 

Requirements 1. Research, compose, and type a scholarly paper based on the scenario described below, and

choose a conclusion scenario to discuss within the body of your paper. Reflect on lessons

learned in this class about technology, privacy concerns, and legal and ethical issues and

addressed each of these concepts in the paper, reflecting on the use of smartphones and social

media in healthcare. Consider the consequences of such a scenario. Do not limit your review of

the literature to the nursing discipline only because other health professionals are using the

technology, and you may need to apply critical thinking skills to its applications in this scenario.

2. Use Microsoft Word and APA formatting. Consult your copy of the Publication Manual of the

American Psychological Association, sixth edition, as well as the resources in Doc Sharing if you

have questions (e.g., margin size, font type and size (point), use of third person, etc.). Take

 

 

NR360 INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN HEALTHCARE

 

NR360 We Can But Dare We.docx Revised 5 ‐ 9 ‐ 16 DA/LS/psb 07.14.16 2

advantage of the writing service SmartThinking, which is accessed by clicking on the link called

the Tutor Source, found under the Course Home area.

3. The length of the paper should be four to five pages, excluding the title page and the reference

page. Limit the references to a few key sources (minimum of three required).

4. The paper will contain an introduction that catches the attention of the reader, states the

purpose of the paper, and provides a narrative outline of what will follow (i.e., the assignment

criteria). Essay: We Can But Dare We

5. In the body of the paper, discuss the scenario in relation to HIPAA, legal, and other regulatory

requirements that apply to the scenario and the ending you chose. Demonstrate support from sources of evidence (references) included as in‐text citations.

6. Choose and identify one of the four possible endings provided for the scenario, and construct

your paper based on its implications to the scenario. Make recommendations about what should

have been done and what could be done to correct or mitigate the problems caused by the

scenario and the ending you chose. Demonstrate support from sources of evidence (references)

included as in‐text citations.

7. Present the advantages and disadvantages of using smartphones and social media in healthcare

and describe professional and ethical principles to the appropriate use of this technology, based

on facts from supporting sources of evidence, which must be included as in‐text citations.

8. The paper’s conclusion should summarize what you learned and make reflections about them to

your practice.

9. Use the “Directions and Assignment Criteria” and “Grading Rubric” below to guide your writing

and ensure that all components are complete. Essay: We Can But Dare We

 

10. Review the section on Academic Honesty found in the Chamberlain Course Policies. All work

must be original (in your own words). Papers will automatically be submitted to TurnItIn when

submitted to the Dropbox.

11. Submit the completed paper to the “We Can, but Dare We?” Dropbox by the end of Week 3.

Please refer to the Syllabus for due dates for this assignment. For online students, please post

questions about this assignment to the weekly Q & A Forums so that the entire class may view

the answers.

 

 

Preparing for the Assignment

BACKGROUND Healthcare is readily embracing any technology to improve patient outcomes, streamline operations,

and lower costs, but we must also consider the impact of such technology on privacy and patient care.

This technology includes the use of social media applications, such as Facebook, Instagram, MySpace,

Twitter, and LinkedIn on smartphones.

 

 

NR360 INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN HEALTHCARE

 

NR360 We Can But Dare We.docx Revised 5 ‐ 9 ‐ 16 DA/LS/psb 07.14.16 3

In healthcare today, smartphones are widely used for communication, efficiency, and care. Obviously, a

variety of issues (ethical, professional, and legal) from both the personal and hospital perspectives

must be considered. SCENARIO

You are a nurse in the emergency room, working the Friday 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. shift, and your evening has

been filled with the usual mix of drunken belligerent teens, wailing babies, chronic obstructive

pulmonary disease (COPD) exacerbations, falls, fractures, and the routine, regular congestive heart

failure (CHF) patients. Your best friend is texting you from the concert that you had to miss tonight

because you were scheduled to work, and you respond to her between care of patients, jealous that she

is there and you are not. “What a jerk to torture me like this!” you think to yourself.

It is now 2 a.m., and the medics radio once again, notifying you of an incoming motor vehicle accident

victim, ETA of 5 minutes. You sigh and opt to use the restroom, rather than getting that much‐needed

cup of coffee, and prepare a room for your next patient. The medics roll in and begin to fill you in. The

patient is a 28‐year‐old male, a passenger on a bus that was involved in a crash, leaving the vehicle

overturned after rolling over an embankment. There were several fatalities among the bus passengers,

and “this victim has remained unconscious, though his vitals are currently” . . . and as you start to focus

on the patient, you take a second look. Can it be? It is! The lead singer, Jerod, from the band “Blue

Lizards,” who you have adored since you first heard his voice! The band had just left the concert that

you had missed last evening when the accident occurred. You quickly text your best friend . . . “Can you

believe?” and she responds with “Yeah, right. PROVE IT.” So you quickly snap a picture with your

smartphone, when alone with the patient, and send it to her. Can’t hurt, right? Celebrities are “public

property,” and that’s a part of their life, right? Just for good measure, you snap a few more pictures of

the unconscious singer in various stages of undress and then a shot of his home address, phone number,

and demographic information from his electronic health record. You sit your phone down on the

bedside table for a minute as you continue your assessment of the patient. Essay: We Can But Dare We

At 7:00 a.m., you drag your tired body home and straight to bed after a long but eventful night.

 

What happens next? Choose an ending to the scenario, and construct your paper based on those

reflections:

1. You are the following nurse on the day shift and discover the night nurse’s phone on the bedside

table. While trying to figure out to whom it belongs, you open the phone and see the

photographs taken the night before. Holy moly! What a find, and nobody could trace you to the

photos.

2. You receive a call from the gossip paper the Gossip Gazette, offering you $20,000 for the photos

you have taken (courtesy of your best friend). Your identity would never be revealed, and you

desperately need a new car and are behind on some bills.

3. You go on Facebook, on your day off, and talk about the night you had at work and how you

didn’t really feel as bad having to miss the concert, because you actually got to meet Jerod in

person and even “Got his number!” You then post a picture of Jerod on Facebook and

 

 

NR360 INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN HEALTHCARE

 

NR360 We Can But Dare We.docx Revised 5 ‐ 9 ‐ 16 DA/LS/psb 07.14.16 4

Instagram, figuring that most of your contacts would never recognize him anyway. It’s your day

off and your personal time, so no harm, no foul, right?

4. You receive a message the next morning from a peer at work that there is a big investigation

being conducted at work due to a HIPAA violation and that it involved a celebrity who had been

admitted to the hospital. The word is that legal action is being taken against the hospital due to

some photos that were sold to the Gossip Gazette. Knowing that the photo you sent is safe with

your best friend, you reach for your smartphone, but it is nowhere to be found. Essay: We Can But Dare We

 

 

 

NR360 INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN HEALTHCARE

 

NR360 We Can But Dare We.docx Revised 5 ‐ 9 ‐ 16 DA/LS/psb 07.14.16 5

Directions and Assignment Criteria

Assignment Criteria Points % Description

Introduction 40

points 40 17%

 

Catches the attention of the reader States

the purpose of the paper

Provides a narrative outline of the paper (i.e., the assignment criteria).

HIPAA, Legal, & Regulatory Discussion 40 points

40 17% Discussion the following as they apply to the use of cellphones and social media in healthcare: o

HIPAA/regulatory requirements o Other legal requirements appropriate to the

use of this technology Demonstrate support from sources of evidence

included as in‐text citations.

Scenario Ending & Recommendations

50 points

 

50 21%

 

Choose and identify one of the four possible endings provided for the scenario. Make recommendations about what should have been

done and what could be done to correct or mitigate

the problems caused by the scenario and the ending

you chose. Demonstrate support from sources of evidence

included as in‐text citations.

Advantages and Disadvantages

50 points

50 21% Discuss at least two (2) advantages and two (2) disadvantages of using smartphones and social media

in healthcare

Describe professional and ethical principles to the appropriate use of this technology

Demonstrate support from sources of evidence included as in‐text citations.

Conclusion and Reflections

30 points 30 12%

 

Summarize what you learned Make reflections about lessons learned to your

practice.

Scholarly Writing and APA Format

30 points

30 12%

Title page, running head, & page numbers are correct.

Use Microsoft Word and APA (6th ed.) formatting Length is 4‐5 pages (excludes title & reference pages).

At least 3 references are used, listed in APA format

References match in text citations in APA format

Spelling, grammar, & mechanics are correct. Essay: We Can But Dare We

Total 240 100%

 

 

 

NR360 INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN HEALTHCARE

 

NR360 WECANBUTDAREWE Guidelines.docxRevised 05 /09/ 18 DA SME/psb 07.14.16 6

Grading Rubric

Assignment

Criteria Outstanding or Highest Level of Performance

 

A (92–100%)

Very Good or High Level of

Performance

B (84–91%)

Competent or Satisfactory

Level of Performance

C (76–83%)

Poor, Failing or

Unsatisfactory Level of

Performance F

(0–75%)

Introduction 40

points The student catches the reader’s attention, states the paper’s purpose, and provides a narrative outline of the paper’s body. Essay: We Can But Dare We

 

 

35–40 points

One of the following is missing or inadequate: attention‐catching statement(s), paper’s purpose, or a narrative outline of the paper’s body.

 

30–34 points

Two of the following are missing or inadequate: attention‐catching statement(s), paper’s purpose, or a narrative outline of the paper’s body.

 

26–29 points

Three of the following are missing or inadequate: attention‐catching statement(s), paper’s purpose, or a narrative outline of the paper’s body. Essay: We Can But Dare We

 

0–25 points

HIPAA, Legal, & Regulatory Discussion 40 points

The discussion of the following as they apply to the use of cellphones and social media in healthcare, is thoroughly addressed:

• HIPAA/regulatory requirements

• Other legal requirements appropriate to the use of this technology

Demonstrated support from sources of evidence included as intext citations.

35–40 points

The discussion of the following as they apply to the use of cellphones and social media in healthcare, is lacking in one or more component:

• HIPAA/regulatory requirements

• Other legal requirements appropriate to the use of this technology

or Support is not demonstrated adequately from sources of evidence included as in‐text citations.

30–34 points

The discussion of the following as they apply to the use of cellphones and social media in healthcare, is lacking in one or more component:

• HIPAA/regulatory requirements

• Other legal requirements appropriate to the use of this technology

and Support is not demonstrated adequately from sources of evidence included as in‐text citations.

26–29 points

The discussion of the following as they apply to the use of cellphones and social media in healthcare, is lacking both components: • HIPAA/regulatory requirements • Other legal requirements appropriate to the use of this technology

and Support is not demonstrated adequately from sources of evidence included as in‐text citations. Essay: We Can But Dare We

0–25 points

 

 

NR360 INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN HEALTHCARE

 

NR360 WECANBUTDAREWE Guidelines.docxRevised 05 /09/ 18 DA SME/psb 07.14.16 7

Scenario Ending & Recommendations

50 points

 

Included all of the following elements sufficiently: • Identify one of the four possible

endings provided for the scenario.

Included all of the following elements but did not develop at least one area substantively : • Identify one of the four possible

endings provided for the scenario.

Included all of the following

elements but did not develop at

two or more area substantively : •

Identify one of the four possible

endings provided for the scenario.

Did not included the following elements substantively : • Identify one of the four possible

endings provided for the scenario. Essay: We Can But Dare We

 

 

 

• Made recommendations about what should have been done. • Made recommendations about what could be done to correct or mitigate the problems caused by the scenario and the ending chosen. • Demonstrated support from sources of evidence included as intext citations.

 

45‐50 points

• Made recommendations about what should have been done. • Made recommendations about what could be done to correct or mitigate the problems caused by the scenario and the ending chosen. Or • Did not demonstrated support from sources of evidence included as in‐text citations.

40‐44 points

• Made recommendations about what should have been done. • Made recommendations about what could be done to correct or mitigate the problems caused by the scenario and the ending chosen. Or • Did not demonstrated support from sources of evidence included as in‐text citations.

36‐39 points

• Made recommendations about what should have been done. • Made recommendations about what could be done to correct or mitigate the problems caused by the scenario and the ending chosen. Or • Did not demonstrated support from sources of evidence included as in‐text citations. Essay: We Can But Dare We

 

0‐35 points

 

 

NR360 INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN HEALTHCARE

 

NR360 WECANBUTDAREWE Guidelines.docxRevised 05 /09/ 18 DA SME/psb 07.14.16 8

Advantages and Disadvantages

50 points

 

Met all of the following criteria: • Discussed at least two (2) advantages and two (2) disadvantages of using smartphones and social media in healthcare • Described professional and ethical principles to the appropriate use of this technology • Demonstrated support from sources of evidence included as intext citations. Essay: We Can But Dare We

45‐50 points

Did not meet one of the following criteria: • Discussed at least two (2) advantages and two (2) disadvantages of using smartphones and social media in healthcare • Described professional and ethical principles to the appropriate use of this technology • Demonstrated support from sources of evidence included as intext citations.

40‐44 points

Did not meet two or more of the following criteria: • Discussed at least two (2) advantages and two (2) disadvantages of using smartphones and social media in healthcare • Described professional and ethical principles to the appropriate use of this technology • Demonstrated support from sources of evidence included as intext citations.

36—39 points

Did not meet Three or more of the following criteria: • Discussed at least two (2) advantages and two (2) disadvantages of using smartphones and social media in healthcare • Described professional and ethical principles to the appropriate use of this technology • Demonstrated support from sources of evidence included as intext citations.

0‐35 points

Conclusion and Reflections 30 points

Met the following criteria substantively: • Summarized what you learned • Made reflections about lessons learned to your practice.

25‐30 points

Did not meet at least one of the following criteria substantively: • Summarize what you learned • Make reflections about lessons learned to your practice.

20‐24 points

Did not meet either of the following criteria substantively: • Summarize what you learned • Make reflections about lessons learned to your practice. Essay: We Can But Dare We

16‐19 points

Did not include a formal conclusion paragraph

 

 

 

0–15 points

 

Scholarly Writing and APA Format

30 points

The following

points

• 6 points

are achieved by successful implementation of each scholarly writing/APA element:

Title page, running head, & page numbers are correct.

• 4 points Use Microsoft Word and APA (6th ed.) formatting

• 2 point Length is 4‐5 pages (excludes title & reference pages).

• 6 points At least 3 references are used, listed in APA format

• 6 points References match in text citations in APA format

 

 

NR360 INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN HEALTHCARE

 

NR360 WECANBUTDAREWE Guidelines.docxRevised 05 /09/ 18 DA SME/psb 07.14.16 9

• 4 points Spelling/mechanics & grammar are correct.

• 2 point Scholarly writing style is used

Total Points Possible = /240 Points